clock menu more-arrow no yes
Key Lime Pie at Peche
Key Lime Pie at Peche
Brasted

13 Must-Eat-Now Pies in New Orleans

View as Map
Key Lime Pie at Peche
| Brasted

In terms of sweet stuff, there are two kinds of people: pie people and cake people. Cakes tend to be sweet through and through, while pie has a variety of crust sweetness to complement the filling. This map focuses on sweet/dessert pies only, so apologies to calzone lovers.

New Orleans' pie game waxes and wanes. Over the past year, pie shop P's & Q's subsumed into HiVolt's second location, and District Hand Pie & Coffee Bar stopped serving hand pies and is now another District Donut outpost.

When a city has such iconic and unique non-pie desserts like doberge, king cake, and bread pudding, pie can be left in the corner (except when it comes to pecan pie, of course). But not only are more and more bakeries offering pie options, but several restaurants are well known for elevating specific pies, which creates the opportunity to find pie in unexpected places.

So hop on the pie train and head for destination: delicious, from tiny corner bakeries to hugely popular restaurants.

Please note, these spots are arranged by neighborhood, not by ranking. Don't see a favorite? Leave a comment or send Eater a tip.

Animated doughnuts

Read More
Note: Restaurants on this map are listed geographically.

1. Boucherie

Copy Link
8115 Jeannette St
New Orleans, LA 70118
(504) 862-5514
Visit Website
The spicy-sweet Thai Chili Chocolate Chess pie is a fixture on Boucherie's menu, but the kitchen also whips up pie specials on the regular, like blueberry-blue cheese fried hand pie, pecan, or peanut butter fig pie.

2. Clancy's

Copy Link
6100 Annunciation St
New Orleans, LA 70118
(504) 895-1111
Visit Website
The white-tablecloth neighborhood restaurant is famous for its frozen lemon icebox pie with graham cracker crust, a variation of the traditional key lime pie.

3. Cowbell

Copy Link
8801 Oak St
New Orleans, LA 70118
(504) 866-4222
Visit Website
No trip to Cowbell - no matter how much you stuff your face with burgers, fries, and/or mac & cheese - is complete without their piping hot, individual sized apple pie because - do I really have to say any more?

4. Emeril's

Copy Link
800 Tchoupitoulas St
New Orleans, LA 70130
(504) 528-9393
Visit Website
Emeril's (The Mothership) serves two pie confections that fit the big flavors swerved with a deft touch that permeates the entire menu. The legendary banana cream pie with caramel and chocolate sauces has been on the Emeril's menu from Day One of opening, and also the chocolate peanut butter pie.

5. Gracious Bakery + Cafe

Copy Link
1000 S Jefferson Davis Pkwy
New Orleans, LA 70125
(504) 301-3709
Visit Website
Big pie, small pie, slice of pie, hand pie... Gracious will give you what you crave.

6. High Hat

Copy Link
4510 Freret St
New Orleans, LA 70115
(504) 754-1336
Visit Website
The High Hat has a deep appreciation of the healing power of pie. Their regular menu always has chocolate chess pie and there's always at least one pie of the day to choose from. When they ask if you want ice cream or whipped cream, tell them "both." ALWAYS ANSWER BOTH.

7. Noodle & Pie

Copy Link
741 State St
New Orleans, LA 70118
(504) 252-9431
Visit Website
A Japanese ramen joint with a variety of pie both traditional (peanut butter chocolate, peach, coconut key lime) and Asian ingredient/flavor profile-tinged like: Vietnamese Iced Coffee Pie with iced coffee gelatin, Iced coffee cream layer and condensed milk; Spicy Thai Peanut Buttercup Pie with chocolate cookie crust, spiced milk chocolate and chantilly cream; or Oolong Honey Shoofly Pie.

8. Pêche

Copy Link
800 Magazine St
New Orleans, LA 70130
(504) 522-1744
Visit Website
Great key lime pie for the traditionalists and a salted peanut pie for those who like to mix it up. Chantilly cream and/or housemade ice cream completes the picture... and don't forget to check for seasonal pie specials on the menu as well.

9. The Camellia Grill

Copy Link
626 S Carrollton Ave
New Orleans, LA 70118
(504) 309-2679
There's a lot of excellent pecan pie in this town, but you'd be hard pressed to find flattop grilled pecan pie as is the signature move at this super friendly, bustling diner. The sugars caramelize, the pecans toast up a bit, and it's all warm and gooey topped with rapidly melting vanilla ice cream.

10. The Caribbean Room

Copy Link
2031 Saint Charles Ave
New Orleans, LA 70130
(504) 323-1500
Visit Website
John Besh and Co are bringing back the Mile High Ice Cream Pie from days of yore. This comically tall confection of vanilla, chocolate, and peppermint ice cream is topped with meringue and finished with chocolate sauce tableside. It's also memorialized in the lobby of the Pontchartrain Hotel (where the Caribbean Room is located) with a painting of Lil Wayne eating a slice.
Randy Schmidt/Caribbean Room

11. The Joint

Copy Link
701 Mazant St
New Orleans, LA 70117
(504) 949-3232
Visit Website
Often, after eating a lot of smoked meat at The Joint, one would think that dessert is an impossibility. Pro tip: Make it happen for the Joint's pecan pie, key lime pie, or peanut butter pie, whatever you're in the mood for. Unless that mood doesn't include pie, in which case, WHUT.

12. Willa Jean

Copy Link
611 Okeefe Ave
New Orleans, LA 70113
(504) 509-7334
Visit Website
Willa Jean is basically a carb and sugar factory built to delight and amaze. As is everything else baked here, the pies are amazeballs.

13. GW Fins

Copy Link
808 Bienville St
New Orleans, LA 70112
(504) 581-3467
Visit Website
Sure this French Quarter restaurant is regarded as one of the best seafood restaurants in New Orleans, but here's a secret— It's also a must-visit for the Salty Malty pie, with salted vanilla ice cream, malt powder, caramel sauce and a pretzel crust. It's sensory bliss.
GW Fins

1. Boucherie

8115 Jeannette St, New Orleans, LA 70118
The spicy-sweet Thai Chili Chocolate Chess pie is a fixture on Boucherie's menu, but the kitchen also whips up pie specials on the regular, like blueberry-blue cheese fried hand pie, pecan, or peanut butter fig pie.
8115 Jeannette St
New Orleans, LA 70118

2. Clancy's

6100 Annunciation St, New Orleans, LA 70118
The white-tablecloth neighborhood restaurant is famous for its frozen lemon icebox pie with graham cracker crust, a variation of the traditional key lime pie.
6100 Annunciation St
New Orleans, LA 70118

3. Cowbell

8801 Oak St, New Orleans, LA 70118
No trip to Cowbell - no matter how much you stuff your face with burgers, fries, and/or mac & cheese - is complete without their piping hot, individual sized apple pie because - do I really have to say any more?
8801 Oak St
New Orleans, LA 70118

4. Emeril's

800 Tchoupitoulas St, New Orleans, LA 70130
Emeril's (The Mothership) serves two pie confections that fit the big flavors swerved with a deft touch that permeates the entire menu. The legendary banana cream pie with caramel and chocolate sauces has been on the Emeril's menu from Day One of opening, and also the chocolate peanut butter pie.
800 Tchoupitoulas St
New Orleans, LA 70130

5. Gracious Bakery + Cafe

1000 S Jefferson Davis Pkwy, New Orleans, LA 70125
Big pie, small pie, slice of pie, hand pie... Gracious will give you what you crave.
1000 S Jefferson Davis Pkwy
New Orleans, LA 70125

6. High Hat

4510 Freret St, New Orleans, LA 70115
The High Hat has a deep appreciation of the healing power of pie. Their regular menu always has chocolate chess pie and there's always at least one pie of the day to choose from. When they ask if you want ice cream or whipped cream, tell them "both." ALWAYS ANSWER BOTH.
4510 Freret St
New Orleans, LA 70115

7. Noodle & Pie

741 State St, New Orleans, LA 70118
A Japanese ramen joint with a variety of pie both traditional (peanut butter chocolate, peach, coconut key lime) and Asian ingredient/flavor profile-tinged like: Vietnamese Iced Coffee Pie with iced coffee gelatin, Iced coffee cream layer and condensed milk; Spicy Thai Peanut Buttercup Pie with chocolate cookie crust, spiced milk chocolate and chantilly cream; or Oolong Honey Shoofly Pie.
741 State St
New Orleans, LA 70118

8. Pêche

800 Magazine St, New Orleans, LA 70130
Great key lime pie for the traditionalists and a salted peanut pie for those who like to mix it up. Chantilly cream and/or housemade ice cream completes the picture... and don't forget to check for seasonal pie specials on the menu as well.
800 Magazine St
New Orleans, LA 70130

9. The Camellia Grill

626 S Carrollton Ave, New Orleans, LA 70118
There's a lot of excellent pecan pie in this town, but you'd be hard pressed to find flattop grilled pecan pie as is the signature move at this super friendly, bustling diner. The sugars caramelize, the pecans toast up a bit, and it's all warm and gooey topped with rapidly melting vanilla ice cream.
626 S Carrollton Ave
New Orleans, LA 70118

10. The Caribbean Room

2031 Saint Charles Ave, New Orleans, LA 70130
Randy Schmidt/Caribbean Room
John Besh and Co are bringing back the Mile High Ice Cream Pie from days of yore. This comically tall confection of vanilla, chocolate, and peppermint ice cream is topped with meringue and finished with chocolate sauce tableside. It's also memorialized in the lobby of the Pontchartrain Hotel (where the Caribbean Room is located) with a painting of Lil Wayne eating a slice.
2031 Saint Charles Ave
New Orleans, LA 70130

11. The Joint

701 Mazant St, New Orleans, LA 70117
Often, after eating a lot of smoked meat at The Joint, one would think that dessert is an impossibility. Pro tip: Make it happen for the Joint's pecan pie, key lime pie, or peanut butter pie, whatever you're in the mood for. Unless that mood doesn't include pie, in which case, WHUT.
701 Mazant St
New Orleans, LA 70117

12. Willa Jean

611 Okeefe Ave, New Orleans, LA 70113
Willa Jean is basically a carb and sugar factory built to delight and amaze. As is everything else baked here, the pies are amazeballs.
611 Okeefe Ave
New Orleans, LA 70113

13. GW Fins

808 Bienville St, New Orleans, LA 70112
GW Fins
Sure this French Quarter restaurant is regarded as one of the best seafood restaurants in New Orleans, but here's a secret— It's also a must-visit for the Salty Malty pie, with salted vanilla ice cream, malt powder, caramel sauce and a pretzel crust. It's sensory bliss.
808 Bienville St
New Orleans, LA 70112

Related Maps