clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Where to Pick Up Pies in New Orleans This Thanksgiving

There’s still time to get orders in for blueberry elderflower, apple rosemary, gingered pumpkin, and more

Bywater Bakery’s blueberry elderflower pie
Bywater Bakery

This Thanksgiving, bakeries in New Orleans — which stands on ancestral Indigenous land originally inhabited by the Chitimacha — are hoping families will leave the desserts to them. And what better excuse to try out this year’s creations than to free up more time to spend with loved ones? After you’ve planned your main meal for November 25, consult this guide to seek out the right pie to end with, from the traditional to the unexpected.

The holiday is just two weeks away, but there’s still time to preorder pie from New Orleans’s best bakeries. Here are Eater’s top picks, listed alphabetically. Did we miss your favorite place to get pie for the holidays? Let us know.

For where to order Thanksgiving turkey, sides, and fresh-baked bread this year, see Eater’s guide here.

Bywater Bakery

3624 Dauphine St., Bywater
Bywater Bakery is consistent in offering the most options for Thanksgiving pie, and this year is no different. Choose from butterscotch pecan; chocolate peanut butter; apple rosemary; sweet potato chiffon; butternut squash pecan praline; and the amazing blueberry elderflower (vegan!). They’re all $27; a good deal for pies of this quality and craftsmanship. To order: Call 504-336-3336, email, or order on the website.

Gracious Bakery

4930 Prytania St., Uptown or 1000 Norman Francis Parkway, Mid City
Gracious has some great pie options available for pickup at the Uptown or Mid City locations this year, including lemon icebox, Louisiana pecan, and apple crumble.
To order: Order online on or before Monday, November 22 for pickup on Wednesday, November 24.

La Boulangerie

4600 Magazine St. #1518, Uptown
In addition to La Boulangerie’s menu of starters and breads, there’s also just about every pie, tart, or cake, from pumpkin, apple, and pecan, to chocolate cream, lemon meringue tart, and chocolate ganache.
To order: Preorder here by Sunday, November 21 to pickup Tuesday, or Wednesday.

La Boulangerie

La Petite Sophie Patisserie

9047 Jefferson Hwy, River Ridge
The lovely La Petite Grocery has all of their regular pastries available to order for Thanksgiving, as well as apple galette, pumpkin pie, pumpkin cheesecake, pecan tart, and a brioche fruit tart.
To order: Call 504-667-3472 by Friday Nov. 19 at noon to pickup on November 24.

The Larder

3005 Veterans Memorial Blvd., Metairie
Alison Vega-Knoll and Chris Wilson’s year-old gourmet market is offering pumpkin and pecan pies to feed 8, for $34 and $36, respectively.
To order: Call 504-766-6157 to place your order by November 20 with pickup by drive-thru window on the 24th.

Laurel Street Bakery

2701 S. Broad St., Mid City
Keep it seasonal with a traditional pumpkin, pecan, or sweet sour cream apple, or go fruity with peach or blueberry lattice from Laurel Street Bakery. For non-pie options, the bakery is also offering pumpkin bread pudding, gingerbread cake, apple bundt cake, or chocolate mousse cake.
To order: Order online by Monday, 11/22 for pick up on Wednesday, 11/24 by 1 p.m.

Levee Baking Co.

3138 Magazine St., Irish Channel
Thanksgiving ordering is live at Levee Baking, where the talented Christina Balzebre is slinging chocolate buttermilk, roasted sweet potato, and lemon meringue.
To order: First-come, first-served; pickups are Wednesday, November 24.

Mayhew Bakery

3201 Orleans Ave, Bayou St. John
Kelly Mayhew’s delightful bakery has pumpkin, bourbon pecan, Dutch apple, chocolate meringue, and excitingly, black cherry pies available this year, ranging from $18 to $28 (more details found here).
To order: Call 504-702-8078 or order online here by November 19 for pickup.

Windowsill Pies

4714 Freret St., Freret
If you haven’t tried the fairly new Windowsill Pies, Thanksgiving is the time. Offering some of the most creative options this year, Windowsill has almond-laced apple, Amaretto pear and dried cherry, an apple Frangipane tart with Grand Marnier glaze, and gingered pumpkin tart with candied pepitas. They’re all on the slightly pricier side ($39-$40), but are true works of art.
To order: Order online by November 18 for pickup.

Gingered pumpkin tart with candied pepitas from Windowsill
Windowsill Pies

Sign up for the newsletter Sign up for the Eater New Orleans newsletter

The freshest news from the local food world